My friend Jacob Richman wrote a page on his web site explaining why he will vote Ichud Leumi (NUP). As a person who has traditionally voted for religious/Zionist parties – I feel compelled to answer Jacob in public.
There are a number of flaws in his argumentations regarding the National Union Party (NUP)
1. The NUP doesn’t have a national agenda – i.e. they don’t have positions on economics, industry, trade, energy, environment, transportation and healthcare in their platform. They are a “one trick pony”
The country runs on taxes – without a strong economy the entire question is moot. I believe that our future is at stake on the economic issues and since the NUP doesn’t even have an economic platform – they are non-starters in my book.
2. The NUP has neither electoral power nor post-elections political power – which brings me to my third point
3. They are politically weak (and whatever political clout they have is generally wasted on the usual internecine politics endemic to the right and religious parties). As a result – they will never be able to keep their promise of preserving Erez Israel to their voters. It’s like me promising you that I’ll go to the supermarket and shop for you without having enough money to pay for the groceries at the checkout counter.
4. The country is better served with 2 large parties with clear national agendas that represent large portions of the electorate. By supporting the continued existence of small parties like the NUP we weaken the democratic process not strenghten it. Crucial national decisions must be decided on the basis of a majority vote not on the basis of coalition in-fighting and log-rolling.
Danny,
To be fair to your readers, they should be given the chance to read the full text of my reasons at:
http://www.jr.co.il/ichud-leumi/index.html
I want the Likud to win enough seats to form the coaltion but I feel that coalition partners today have a better chance of influencing Bibi then his own party members. Let’s not forget how Sharon railroaded us out of Gaza (and see the results) when his own party voted against it. IF his coalition partners left the government, the disengagement would not have happened. Yes, Ichud Leumi does not have a full platform on all issues but they have 3-4 issues that I find importnat enough to give them my vote and support.
I agree with you that we should have a two party system but the way we elect the officials must change. This means local / district elections and the ability to take to task your elected representative.
Until the whole system is overhauled, we will have to live with what we have today. Maybe raise the election percentage threshold a bit more.
Having a 2 party system without direct representatives that are answerable to the public can be more dangerous than todays 6-7 party
coalition governments.
My 8 agurot (my 2 cents)
Shavua Tov and
Have a fruitful Tu B’Shvat,
Jacob